Death on May Morning (1938) by Max Dalman
Murder in Oxford! The red-headed son of a South American dictator is shot in sniper-like fashion while attending the May Morning festivities. Chief Inspector Osborne and local police aren't looking forward to the hordes of journalists that will be buzzing around an apparently politically-motivated murder. And the press has stolen a march on them--Philip Hardman, a gossip columnist, was one of the group around Juan da Valgas when the shooting occurred. Hardman rushes to tell the Oxford authorities and, incidentally, to phone his editor with the scoop. His editor tells him to stick to the story (even if it is outside his usual remit) and Hardman decides to go full amateur detective. If the story weren't enough to keep him in Oxford, there's also Mary Douglas, lovely undergraduate and cousin to Wallis Van Weiman.
Initially, Hardman has Van Weiman on his list of suspects, but when the American scholar (and former journalist himself) is also killed, he must change his theories. His investigations dovetail with Osborne's and the two men go through a variety of possibilities--from Van Weiman seeing/knowing something important about the da Valgas killing to mistaken identity (both victims had bright red hair) to a maniac with vendetta against red-heads. Hardman and Osborne each, through separate means, land on the correct villain, but are they too late? The killer has taken Mary hostage and is holed up in an old farm building....
As frequently happens in some of these Golden Age detective novels, we take a sharp turn from standard detective story to adventure/thriller. For two-thirds (or more) of the book, Hardman and Osborne are hunting clues and interviewing suspects/witnesses and trying on theories. Then, as soon as they get close to the solution, we're off on a high-octane thriller. Hardman is attacked (twice). The killer grabs the girl and threatens to kill her if not allowed to escape. There is shoot-out with the police. Hardman (who had just been shot before the grand finale) gets to play hero--scaling an outer wall while injured and surprising/overpowering the murderer. Not long before a policeman who had been set to guard Mary was knocked out cold in a tussle with our villain, but was up and ready for action in true Sexton Blake fashion as soon as he was found. Exhilarating stuff, if a tad unbelievable.
The mystery itself is a good one and the first half is well-done with red herrings and possibilities. I enjoyed watching both Osborne and Hardman follow their different tracks to the solution. But I must say that neither Osborne nor Hardman are terribly swift on the draw. As soon as we knew that Van Weiman had been writing to the states for information and certain people had been cleared, there was only one possible suspect left--if Dalman was playing fair and wasn't going to spring a villain on us at the last minute. Given that he decided to give us a Sexton Blakesque ending, I suppose that wasn't out of the realm of possibility, but I was pinning my hopes on a fair-play villain. ★★★ and 1/2
First line: Under the first crashing peal of the bells the tower roof trembled beneath the feet of the twenty or thirty people who still stood there.
"If you must do detective work, Mr. Hardman, please remember that nothing should be touched or moved unnecessarily without completing investigations as far as possible." [Inspector Osborne; p. 48]
"If you can't catch the murderer, you might get yourself knocked on the head again. It's better than nothing." [Jerrold; p. 72]
Last line: "'And deep into the dying day the happy Princess followed him.'"
*********************
Deaths = 2 (one shot; one stabbed) [Plus 8 unnamed policemen--honestly, can we please name all our victims so they can be counted for the Medical Examiner's Challenge? Is that too much to ask?]

.jpg)
.jpg)






.jpg)
.jpg)
























