Keep It Quiet (1935) by Richard Hull
There's nothing like a gentlemen's club for peace and quiet. A place for a drink and a cigar, good food, good company, and...if desired...a good friendly rivalry. And for those who like to complain, a place to do so in the most genteel way possible. But there should be no place for murder. Or even the suspicion of murder. Or a suspicious death of any sort. So...when Mr. Morrison, one of the Whitehall Club's grand champion complainers, is found dead in his chair after dinner and the chef confesses to having possibly mixed up a bottle of perchloride of mercury--humorously poured into a vanilla bottle by his wife--with the legitimate bottle of vanilla {Morrison had complained about the lack of enough vanilla flavor in his iced souffle}, it is Ford's (the Club's secretary) first thought that he must keep it quiet at all costs.
Fortunately, Morrison's doctor, Dr. Anstruther, is also a member of the club and wants as little to do with publicity as Ford does. He's willing to give a death certificate with heart failure as the cause and the matter is tidied away very nicely. But then...Ford and Anstruther begin receiving demands from an anonymous blackmailer. He doesn't want money--just the power of watching them squirm and, incidentally, making a few changes here and there around the club. Then there is a second death; this time more obviously a poisoning. So we hush that up too. It's not likely to stay hushed, though. Fellow club member Mr. Cardonnel fancies himself a detective and begins to investigate. But will Cardonnel be the next victim?
This was the first Hull novel that I read (long ago in the mists of time before blogging). And I loved it. The humor of the nervous, ineffectual Ford. The menace of the blackmailer. The interesting take on detective work as practiced by Cardonnel. It's quite well-written and witty and is a really good send-up of gentlemen's clubs. It takes a poke at the methods of Sherlock Holmes while it's at it. Quite good fun and quite the best Hull novel I've read. I put it miles ahead of The Murder of My Aunt (which I just didn't take to). My one complaint is that it is made all too plain way too early who is behind the blackmail and the deaths. A bit longer on the suspense would have one down better. But still--★★★★
First line: In a way it was Benson's fault; or perhaps it was Mrs. Benson's.
Last line: But this time advise him seriously that it would be better if he really kept it quiet.
******************
Deaths 3 (one natural; two poisoned)

.jpg)






.jpg)
.jpg)

























