Mystery Lover...but overall a very eclectic reader. Will read everything from the classics to historical fiction. Biography to essays. Not into horror or much into YA. If you would like me to review a book, then please see my stated review policy BEFORE emailing me. Please Note: This is a book blog. It is not a platform for advertising. Please do NOT contact me to ask that I promote your NON-book websites or products. Thank you.
Pages
Thursday, January 2, 2014
The Poison Belt: Review
Professor Summerlee, Lord John Roxton, and the young reporter Edward Malone all receive urgent telegrams from Challenger requesting their presence at his country home and insisting that they bring along tubes of oxygen. Challenger has arranged for them to watch the end of the world from the confines of a sealed room--with only their meager supply of oxygen to forestall their own death. They are amazed and dismayed to find that the oxygen not only forestalls death, but allows them to survive until the poisonous ether has passed on from Earth's atmosphere. They venture out to survey the terrible results....only to find one more surprise in store.
My take: Sure. We all know now that there is no such thing as ether between the planets. It's all a vacuum. But Doyle was working with what he had and what the science of the day firmly believed. All it takes is a suspension of belief and a step back in time and the story becomes most plausible, indeed. While there are elements of science fiction and speculative fiction to Doyle's story, it is even more evidently a morality play. It teaches us to consider what it really important in our lives and to take more notice of the small, everyday pleasures that we often miss in our hurry to get ahead and get things done. What would we miss most if all of our fellow man and living creatures were suddenly silent? Three stars--as a strict science/speculative fiction it provides an interesting premise, but not a whole lot of action, but as a morality play it is a solid story indeed.
Challenges met: Outdo Yourself, Mount TBR Challenge, Bookish TBR, Read Scotland, Century of Books, Million Pages, How Many Books, 100 Plus Challenge, Vintage SF Month, Science Fiction Experience, Book Bingo, 52 Books in 52 Weeks, A-Z Reading Challenge, 2014 Literary Exploration, European Challenge, Out of This World [poisonous space affecting Earth]
3 comments:
Sorry folks, but I have been getting an incredible amount of spam. I have adjusted my settings and all messages will be moderated from now on. If that does not take care of the problem then I will have to go to the "Prove You're Not a Robot" thing--which I hate as much as you do.
If your name does not appear automatically, please tell me your name in the comment. Otherwise you will just show up as "Unknown." Thanks!
I never mind running into that mysterious "ether". it's a good stand-in for whatever atmosphericness people didn't yet understand, or did understand, and didn't want their characters to have to deal with.
ReplyDeleteI had never thought about some of these older classics as "morality plays", makes me look at them in a whole new light!
What a great review. A book that I would have honestly passed by, you helped to grab my attention.
ReplyDeleteI have a small like for science fiction, but not enough to really have all this knowledge you are sure I would know, (ether in between the planets), but I know it now. Reading further into your review, and your note of 'everyday pleasures' and how we basically take them for granted spoke to me. It's something I have felt much of this last little while. If this book can bring out those thoughts in you, it must be a decent story.
thanks for the nice comments, littleredreviewer and Freda! Doyle has a way with words and it's a great look at what might happen if everyone were gone...
ReplyDelete