Mystery Lover...but overall a very eclectic reader. Will read everything from the classics to historical fiction. Biography to essays. Not into horror or much into YA. If you would like me to review a book, then please see my stated review policy BEFORE emailing me. Please Note: This is a book blog. It is not a platform for advertising. Please do NOT contact me to ask that I promote your NON-book websites or products. Thank you.
Pages
Friday, August 22, 2014
Seventh Son: Review
Seventh Son is the first novel in Orson Scott Card's alternate American history series. It's set in the early 19th Century in an America where folk magic holds sway and the fate of the New World has taken a slightly different path. Yes, there are United States, but not quite the same ones as here in our timeline. Yes, there was a first president, but it wasn't George Washington. And there is an Indian Nation state that has representatives to vote.
In this world, seventh sons are magical and seventh sons of seventh sons are even more magical than their fathers--and quite rare. Alvin Miller, Jr. is such a one. In fact, Alvin is a Maker, a seventh son with the power to not only create new things out of old, but also to make things whole and to heal. He has a destiny that can help create a good positive future for America. But from the moment of his birth an ancient, dark force, the Unmaker, who will stop at nothing to destroy Alvin and prevent him from fulfilling his destiny.
I am just a bit torn on rating this one. I'm pulled towards a four-star rating by the world-building and the fresh, original feel to this American fantasy/alternate reality. The characters are delightful--particularly Peggy (Alvin's far-off "guardian angel") and Alvin and the writing is particularly strong. There is a character called Taleswapper who goes from place to place telling stories and collecting new ones and the entire book reads like a tale told by a grand old storyteller around the fire. But I'm also pulled toward a lower three-star rating by the infusion of religion. You want to create an America that's based on folk magic and secret powers? Cool. You want to set up dark forces to destroy the ones who hold that power for good? Hey, absolutely. I'm all for that Good vs. Evil thing. But...can't we just do that within the folk magic scenario? That's why we created a whole different timeline America, right? I do get the whole Pilgrim/Puritan vs. "witchcraft" background. Salem and witch burning. I know it was part of the early days of America. But was it necessary to bring in religion and make those who represent it the bad guys? Maybe it was--but when I was reading it just didn't settle right.
My other small quibble is that the blurb on my edition made much of the positive role of Native Americans in this version of America and, perhaps, since this is a series there will be more of a Native American presence in the following books. But there is little here. The mention of those who have voting rights. And a man who is healed by Alvin (in an unexpected way) and who goes off to be a prophet to his people. But no real direct contact with Native Americans beyond that. When I specifically polled some of my friends for alternate history books that involved Native Americans, this series was one that was mentioned. I had hoped for more Native American influence in the opening novel.
Quibbles aside, Card is quite the storyteller in Seventh Son and the story was compelling and interesting. I will definitely be looking to read the next book in the series (Red Prophet--perhaps the title is an indication that there will be more Native Americans....). ★★★ and a half.
4 comments:
Sorry folks, but I have been getting an incredible amount of spam. I have adjusted my settings and all messages will be moderated from now on. If that does not take care of the problem then I will have to go to the "Prove You're Not a Robot" thing--which I hate as much as you do.
If your name does not appear automatically, please tell me your name in the comment. Otherwise you will just show up as "Unknown." Thanks!
Gosh, it's a long time since I read those, but IIRC there is a book just about the Native Americans--Red Prophet--and they do show up in other places in the series. I think Alvin goes to live with them for a while? Maybe? Whether you'll like it when you get there, I don't know, I can't remember a thing else.
ReplyDeleteThere's also OSC's Pastwatch, in which some people go back in time to mess with Christopher Columbus and the entire American timeline.
I've heard great things about this author but have yet to read anything by him. I think I like this one, as it connects me to the Native Americans. I am Native Canadian, Métis, actually. This might be a good place to start reading his works. Great review!
ReplyDeleteI read this when I was a kid, but don't really remember much about it. I think I liked it, but my politics know would keep me from reading anything by him. I'll be curious to see what you think if you continue with the series.
ReplyDeleteRyan: I haven't read anything by him for years--Ender's Game was the last (which I loved then)--and probably wouldn't now except this has been sitting on the shelf for so long that I wanted to read it before moving it out of the house (and count it for Mount TBR!).
ReplyDelete